CLOSE

We permit the publication of our auditors’ report, provided the report is published in full only and is accompanied by the full financial statements to which our auditors’ report relates, and is only published on an access-controlled page on your website https://www.hermes-investment.com, to enable users to verify that an auditors’ report by independent accountants has been commissioned by the directors and issued. Such permission to publish is given by us without accepting or assuming any responsibility or liability to any third party users save where we have agreed terms with them in writing.

Our consent is given on condition that before any third party accesses our auditors’ report via the webpage they first document their agreement to the following terms of access to our report via a click-through webpage with an 'I accept' button. The terms to be included on your website are as follows:

I accept and agree for and on behalf of myself and the Trust I represent (each a "recipient") that:

  1. PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”) accepts no liability (including liability for negligence) to each recipient in relation to PwC’s report. The report is provided to each recipient for information purposes only. If a recipient relies on PwC’s report, it does so entirely at its own risk;
  2. No recipient will bring a claim against PwC which relates to the access to the report by a recipient;
  3. Neither PwC’s report, nor information obtained from it, may be made available to anyone else without PwC’s prior written consent, except where required by law or regulation; and
  4. PwC’s report was prepared with Hermes Property Unit Trust's interests in mind. It was not prepared with any recipient's interests in mind or for its use. PwC’s report is not a substitute for any enquiries that a recipient should make. The financial statements are as at 25 March 2016, and thus PwC’s auditors’ report is based on historical information. Any projection of such information or PwC’s opinion thereon to future periods is subject to the risk that changes may occur after the reports are issued and the description of controls may no longer accurately portray the system of internal control. For these reasons, such projection of information to future periods would be inappropriate.
  5. PwC will be entitled to the benefit of and to enforce these terms.
I accept
CLOSE

1. Select your country

  • United Kingdom
  • Austria
  • Australia
  • Belgium
  • Denmark
  • Finland
  • France
  • Germany
  • Iceland
  • Ireland
  • Italy
  • Luxembourg
  • Netherlands
  • Norway
  • Singapore
  • Spain
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • USA
  • Other

2. Select your investor type

  • Financial Advisor
  • Discretionary Investment Manager
  • Wealth Manager
  • Family Office
  • Institutional Investor
  • Investment Consultant
  • Charity, Foundation & Endowment Investor
  • Retail Investor
  • Press
  • None of the above

3. Accept our terms and conditions

Proceed

The Hermes Investment Management website uses cookies to remember your preferences and help us improve the site.
By proceeding, you agree to cookies being placed on your computer.
Read our privacy and cookie policy.

Home / Hermes EOS Blog / Pushing for equal voting rights in the land of égalité and beyond

Pushing for equal voting rights in the land of égalité and beyond

The pending dilution of shareholder rights as a result of the Florange Act in France – which seeks to reward long-term investment – sets a worrying precedent in the country. Even more concerning is that proposed amendments to the EU Shareholder Rights Directive could lead to EU member states implementing similar rewards that could advantage some shareholders over others.

Shareholder inequality
While we are in favour of encouraging long-term investment, we firmly support the principle of ‘one-share, one-vote’, which ensures proportionality between equity ownership and voting powers and economic risk bearing. We believe equal voting rights should be attached to shares regardless of the total holding or other characteristics of an investor. Any divergence from the one-share, one-vote principle is extremely concerning and could have a disenfranchising effect on minority shareholders.

We also have concerns about paying enhanced dividends to long-term shareholders. This practice disadvantages some shareholders, increases investment risk and may reduce management accountability.

In addition, we believe the requirement by the Florange Act to register shares in order to receive double voting rights and loyalty dividends creates an unfair playing field for international investors due to the complexities and costs involved in share registration, limitations on eligibility given the different fund and holding structures and a potential lack of understanding of the Act. Due to the unintended consequence of strengthening large stockholdings over the interests of minority shareholders, the process effectively prevents some investors from being able to benefit from either initiative. In our view, the mechanisms of the Florange Act – which was adopted on 29 March 2014 – will not achieve the objective of long-term investment in a fair and equal manner.

Lessons from Italy
In recent weeks, the Italian government changed its position on a similar law to the relief of global investors.

The Italian government had passed a resolution in July 2014 lowering the majority requirement from two thirds to half the votes cast for companies wanting to implement loyalty shares with double voting rights for investors who have held their shares for two years. The prospect of this law being introduced caused significant concern given that according to the Italian regulator CONSOB approximately 70% of Italian listed companies are majority controlled.

Following pressure from institutional investors and non-executive directors at major Italian companies, Italy’s government succumbed and announced it would not extend the simple majority rule, which expired at the end of January 2015. But prior to the expiry, three prominent Italian companies – Campari, Amplifon and Astaldi – took advantage of the special resolution.

Expanding into Europe
This step forward by Italy has now been overshadowed by proposals to amend the EU Shareholder Rights Directive which could force each EU member state to implement similar rewards for shareholders to those the Florange Act envisaged. The proposals include differential voting rights, loyalty shares and tax incentives for long-term shareholdings.

The proposed amendments are extremely worrying. If enacted, they could not only have devastating effects for minority shareholders but also reduce the attractiveness of European companies as investments.

As in Italy, we sincerely hope investor pressure can prevent this concerning trend from spreading. We have been engaging with French companies on the importance of maintaining equal voting rights for shareholders and will continue our engagement with policy-makers to ensure an optimum outcome for our clients and investors.

Share this post:
Rochelle Giugni Rochelle Giugni works in Hermes EOS’ Business and Client Development team after previously engaging in the consumer goods and retail, financial services and utilities sectors. Prior to joining Hermes EOS, Rochelle worked for a prominent Australian-based corporate advisory firm providing transaction and forensic accounting services. She has worked extensively with distressed businesses and specialised in restructuring and corporate recovery, where she gained hands-on experience across sectors ranging from retail, property, hotel & leisure, agriculture & farming, through to banking & securities. Rochelle is a qualified chartered accountant and holds a degree in Commerce-Accounting and diploma in Business Administration from Macquarie University. She also holds the CFA’s Investment Management Certificate.
Read all articles by Rochelle Giugni

Find posts by author

  • Bill Mackenzie
  • Bruce Duguid
  • Christine Chow
  • Colin Melvin – Global Head of Stewardship
  • Darren Brady
  • Dominic Burke
  • Emma Hunt
  • Freddie Woolfe
  • Hans-Christoph Hirt
  • Jaime Gornsztejn
  • Jennifer Walmsley
  • Jon Brager
  • Justine Lutterodt
  • Karin Ri
  • Leon Kamhi – Head of Responsibility at Hermes investment Management
  • Lui Goldie
  • Mais Hayek
  • Manuel Isaza
  • Mark Sherlock, CFA
  • Matthew Doyle
  • Maxine Wille
  • Michael Viehs
  • Naheeda Rashid
  • Natacha Dimitrijevic
  • Nina Roehrbein
  • Nina Röhrbein
  • Rochelle Giugni
  • Roland Bosch
  • Sachi Suzuki
  • Saker Nusseibeh
  • Tim Goodman
  • Victoria Barron

Find posts by category

  • Select category
  • environment
  • governance
  • social
  • strategy