The near-term outlook for Brazil has taken a dive as political scandals deepen and economic woes mount. Oliver Leyland, Senior Investment Analyst of the Hermes Global Emerging Markets Fund, considers potential outcomes from this turbulence and explains the team’s approach to investing throughout it.
Macro, market malaise
The currency is plummeting, bond yields are rising, and the local stock market is giving up all of its 2015 gains. As a comprehensive barometer of risk, we monitor CDS spreads, which have unsurprisingly moved higher in recent sessions, though are below the heights of March 2015 and yet to price in extreme stress.
Brazil CDS spreads: further to climb?
Source: Bloomberg as at July 2015
Rousseff feels the heat…
The coalition government is splintering and President Dilma Rousseff’s impeachment is becoming a real possibility, after her administration’s approval rating plunged to 7.7% in recent polls. There are two realistic scenarios that could trigger this: first, an accusation of ‘creative accounting’ in the 2014 public accounts, or second, of irregularities in 2014 campaign financing. Should the President be impeached for the former, her Vice President and coalition partner Michel Temer (PMDB) would likely assume the presidency, representing ‘more of the same’ and therefore a continued malaise for the market. Should campaign financing be the cause of impeachment, the coalition government in its entirety would likely have to be replaced, spurring elections and a probable return to power for the opposition and the PSDB under Aecio Neves, the narrow loser in last October’s elections. This outcome would likely result in improved sentiment and risk appetite towards Brazilian markets. An impeachment of the President would not be unprecedented: recall the 1992 impeachment of President Fernando Collor, who was incidentally investigated (with his Lamborghini, Ferrari and Porsche all impounded) as part of the Petrobras ‘Car Wash’ scandal. Not all of Brazil’s institutions can be said to have stopped functioning, however, and in the absence of either growth or stability, at least Brazil’s judicial institutions and democracy remain alive and well.
…As markets go cold on slashed surplus
Compounding the political uncertainty have been economic developments. Last week, the Bovespa lost some of what remaining confidence it had in the Rousseff Administration after the government announced that it would slash the 2015 primary fiscal surplus target from 1.2% of GDP to 0.2%. This is the result of a significant cut to revenue forecasts (lower tax receipts as the recession bites), with no further cuts to spending, and could yet decline to a primary deficit should BRL26bn of ‘extraordinary revenues’ not be realised during the year. A primary surplus of 2% is widely seen as necessary for the stabilisation of the country’s debt. As a consequence, public debt should now continue to increase until at least 2018, raising the risk of a downgrade below investment grade for Brazil’s sovereign debt, which would be the epicentre of economy-wide aftershocks. For 2016, the primary surplus target has fallen from 2.0% to 0.7%, and for 2017 from 2.0% to 1.3%.
In response, the real has hit a 12-year low, and the MSCI Brazil (in dollars) is at levels last seen in November 2008. For an equity market where the short-term bull case is, to a large degree, based upon an improvement in the credibility of economic management and a reduction in the risk premium – rather than a return to sustainable growth – this is certainly damaging.
2015 Budget and first budget directives (BRL bn)
Source: Credit Suisse
For stock pickers, selectivity is essential
August, September and October will be heavy months for news flow in Brazil regarding impeachment, credit ratings, public protests, the ‘Car Wash’ scandal and taxation changes. Several (binary) events could feasibly result in a change of outlook and ultimately government, which could require a reassessment of our views. Brazilian equities are prone to peaks and troughs of euphoria and despair, and overshooting both to the upside and downside is therefore common. Our strategy remains consistent – to wait for good stocks to go on sale, and buy when the price is right (ie. wrong), providing a margin of safety. We currently maintain a material underweight position in Brazil, holding only strong franchises at attractive valuations, including an exporter (which should benefit from BRL depreciation) and two financial companies that will be directly supported by higher interest rates, with the benchmark SELIC interest rate likely to rise beyond 14% in the second half. On a forward-earnings multiple of 11.5x (a 10% premium to its historical average), Brazilian equities currently offer an earnings yield (inverse of the P/E) some 4% below that of the 10-year government bond (13.1%). So a country that may well be attractive to fixed income investors currently offers little valuation support for equity investors, who, like us, must remain extremely selective.
Calendar of political and judicial events
|22 July||Deadline for President Dilma to present her defence to the TCU (Federal accounting office) regarding creative accounting on fiscal metrics in 2014.|
|29 July||Deadline for Dilma to sanction the minimum wage bill that will be valid until 2019.|
|31 July||Congress Reopens after the winter recess.|
|5 August||President Dilma receives a list of three candidates for the National Prosecutor office. The post is currently occupied by Rodrigo Janot, who can be reappointed to the post. Many believe that his substitution could attenuate the Lava Jato investigation. The appointment needs to pass the Senate Constitutional Commission (CCJ).|
|August||TCU should come out with the decision on whether to accept, partially accept, or reject President Dilma’s 2014 accounts. A rejection could give the opposition grounds to begin impeachment procedures.|
|6 August||PT party 10 minute national TV and radio program.|
|16 August||Street protests.|
|31 August||Deadline for government to submit to Congress the budget proposal for 2016.|
|16 September||End of the term of National Prosecutor Janot, if not reappointed.|
|24 September||PMDB party 10 minute national TV and radio program.|
|October||Possible decision of the Electoral Court (TSE) on the case referring to responsibility crime on the 2014 presidential campaign. Consequence could be the annulment of the winning ticket of the 2014 elections.|
Source: J.P. Morgan, Arko Advice
Head of Corporate Communicationsjeannie.firstname.lastname@example.org +44 (0)20 7680 2152 +44 (0)7841 324061Jeannie Dumas
Head of Corporate Communications
Corporate Communications Managermelanie.email@example.com +44 (0)20 7680 2218 + 44 (0)7767 162 317Melanie Bradley
Corporate Communications Manager
Assistant Manager, Corporate Communicationskatie.firstname.lastname@example.org +44 (0)20 7680 2315 +44 (0) 7553 385 276Katie Sunderland
Assistant Manager, Corporate Communications