CLOSE

We permit the publication of our auditors’ report, provided the report is published in full only and is accompanied by the full financial statements to which our auditors’ report relates, and is only published on an access-controlled page on your website https://www.hermes-investment.com, to enable users to verify that an auditors’ report by independent accountants has been commissioned by the directors and issued. Such permission to publish is given by us without accepting or assuming any responsibility or liability to any third party users save where we have agreed terms with them in writing.

Our consent is given on condition that before any third party accesses our auditors’ report via the webpage they first document their agreement to the following terms of access to our report via a click-through webpage with an 'I accept' button. The terms to be included on your website are as follows:

I accept and agree for and on behalf of myself and the Trust I represent (each a "recipient") that:

  1. PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”) accepts no liability (including liability for negligence) to each recipient in relation to PwC’s report. The report is provided to each recipient for information purposes only. If a recipient relies on PwC’s report, it does so entirely at its own risk;
  2. No recipient will bring a claim against PwC which relates to the access to the report by a recipient;
  3. Neither PwC’s report, nor information obtained from it, may be made available to anyone else without PwC’s prior written consent, except where required by law or regulation; and
  4. PwC’s report was prepared with Hermes Property Unit Trust's interests in mind. It was not prepared with any recipient's interests in mind or for its use. PwC’s report is not a substitute for any enquiries that a recipient should make. The financial statements are as at 25 March 2017, and thus PwC’s auditors’ report is based on historical information. Any projection of such information or PwC’s opinion thereon to future periods is subject to the risk that changes may occur after the reports are issued and the description of controls may no longer accurately portray the system of internal control. For these reasons, such projection of information to future periods would be inappropriate.
  5. PwC will be entitled to the benefit of and to enforce these terms.
I accept
CLOSE

1. Select your country

  • United Kingdom
  • Austria
  • Australia
  • Belgium
  • Denmark
  • Finland
  • France
  • Germany
  • Iceland
  • Ireland
  • Italy
  • Luxembourg
  • Netherlands
  • Norway
  • Singapore
  • Spain
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • USA
  • Other

2. Select your investor type

  • Financial Advisor
  • Discretionary Investment Manager
  • Wealth Manager
  • Family Office
  • Institutional Investor
  • Investment Consultant
  • Charity, Foundation & Endowment Investor
  • Retail Investor
  • Press
  • None of the above

3. Accept our terms and conditions

By clicking Proceed I confirm I have read the important information and agree to the terms of use.

Proceed

The Hermes Investment Management website uses cookies to remember your preferences and help us improve the site.
By proceeding, you agree to cookies being placed on your computer.
Read our privacy and cookie notices.

Hermes EOS to call for more effective leadership and management stability at Deutsche Bank AGM

Home / Press Centre / Hermes EOS to call for more effective leadership and management stability at Deutsche Bank AGM

Hans-Christoph Hirt
22 May 2018
EOS

Ahead of the Deutsche Bank AG AGM on Thursday 24 May, Dr. Hans-Christoph Hirt, Head of Hermes EOS at Hermes Investment Management, highlights the questions the Chair needs to answer and explains why the Chair is ultimately responsible for the company’s limited progress in the implementation of a value-creating strategy. He also raises concerns about the high turnover of management and supervisory board members and urges a review and improvement of the selection and nomination processes for management board members and non-executives.

 The Chair needs to answer serious questions regarding CEO turnover and other management board changes
Given the catalogue of challenges Deutsche Bank currently faces, more effective leadership and continuity is needed in its management board. Unfortunately, there continues to be high churn:

  • The appointment of Christian Sewing as the new CEO in April, which was preceded by rumours and leaks, means that Deutsche Bank has now had four CEOs/co-CEOs during the six-year tenure of the Chair, Paul Achleitner. He hand-picked John Cryan, who was initially appointed as co-CEO in mid-2015 (when he was a member of the company’s supervisory board), after overseeing the previous co-CEOs for three years following his own election in 2012
  • In addition, Marcus Schenck, one of Deutsche Bank’s deputy CEOs, appointed to the management board in 2015, and Kim Hammonds, its former COO, appointed in 2016, have either left or will leave the company following the appointment of Christian Sewing as new CEO
  • These changes follow a significant management board purge after the appointment of John Cryan in 2015

The continuing frequent departures of management board members raises the question of whether there are deficiencies in the supervisory board’s selection process of senior executives. Furthermore, we ask whether the management board changes could simply mask an underlying problem, namely, the lack of an implementable strategy that creates value for shareholders and other stakeholders.

The Chair is ultimately responsible for sustainable value creation
While the Chair of the supervisory board of a German public company has no immediate legal responsibility for the development of a strategy and its implementation, he/she is required to be closely involved in related processes under both company law and as part of obligations under the Banking Act. The Chair also leads on the appointment of the CEO and the management board and as such has the means to influence strategy and its implementation. Thus, in our view the Chair bears ultimate responsibility for a company’s sustainable value creation.

Paul Achleitner has not only overseen significant CEO and management board turnover during his six-year tenure but also a number of attempts to define and implement a value creating strategy for Deutsche Bank. This included strategic U-turns, not least regarding both the bank’s retail and asset management businesses, and to date, a failure to move decisively on the troubled investment bank. In our view, he is therefore ultimately responsible for the limited progress Deutsche Bank has made during his tenure in the implementation of a value creating strategy. Paul Achleitner will need to demonstrate more effective leadership at the top of the supervisory board.

The high turnover of supervisory board members may impact its effectiveness
During the tenure of Paul Achleitner, there has been an unusually high turnover on the supervisory board of Deutsche Bank. Some of the changes during the early part of his tenure may have been desirable and well-managed. However, even following the initial supervisory board clear-out, there continues to be significant change, with some members leaving the supervisory board after a single term. This gives rise to the following concerns:

  • The average tenure of the shareholder-elected members on Deutsche Bank’s supervisory board will be just over two years following elections at the AGM.[1] Given the complexity of the bank’s activities, this could mean that they have a limited understanding of the business, which would impact the effectiveness of the supervisory board
  • Moreover, the departure of Henning Kagermann from the supervisory board and subsequently its key committees, leaves a significant vacuum as he has acted as a de facto Senior Independent Director, amongst the shareholder-elected members
  • There appears to be no suitable candidate for the role Henning Kagermann has played over the last years and no apparent chair succession planning

We urge Deutsche Bank to carefully consider the future composition of the supervisory board’s nomination committee and use its reconstitution as an opportunity to review and improve the selection and nomination processes for management board members and non-executives respectively. The nomination committee should also start to consider plans for the succession of Paul Achleitner.

Given the potential conflicts of interest, we do not believe that the nomination committee should comprise representatives of the major shareholders.

The views and opinions contained herein are those of the author and may not necessarily represent views expressed or reflected in other Hermes communications, strategies or products. 

[1] Norbert Winkeljohann will only join the supervisory board in August 2018.

Share this post:
Hans-Christoph Hirt Dr Hans-Christoph Hirt is an executive director and board member at Hermes EOS and as Head of the organisation responsible for the sustainable success of the business. He leads and oversees the global engagement programme and the quality of the services Hermes EOS provides to its clients around the world. Hans also leads some high-profile stewardship activities, including priority engagements with major companies in Asia and Germany, as well as interactions with key regulators and organisations. Prior to joining Hermes EOS, Hans worked with international law firm Ashurst. He is the author of numerous publications on corporate governance and law, responsible investment and stewardship. Currently, he is a member of the Steering Committee of the UN PRI Investor Engagement Clearinghouse and the Shareholder Responsibilities Committee of the International Corporate Governance Network. In 2015, he joined the Institutional Investor Council in Malaysia. Hans is a UK-qualified lawyer, holds degrees in Business Administration from universities in Germany and the UK, the ACCA qualification and a PhD from the London School of Economics (LSE). He continues to be involved in academia as a Corporate Governance Fellow at the LSE’s Financial Markets Group and a Teaching Fellow at University College London. Hans speaks French, German and Mandarin.
Read all articles by Hans-Christoph Hirt

Find posts by author

  • Alex Knox, ACA
  • Andrew Jackson
  • Andrew Parry
  • Claire Gavini
  • Dr Michael Viehs
  • Emeric Chenebaux
  • Eoin Murray
  • Geoffrey Wan, CFA
  • Harriet Steel
  • Ilana Elbim
  • Jonathan Pines, CFA
  • Joseph Buckley
  • Louise Dudley
  • Mark Sherlock, CFA
  • Martin Todd
  • Michael Russell, CFA
  • Michael Vaughan
  • Neil Williams
  • Nick Spooner
  • Nina Röhrbein
  • Peter Hofbauer
  • Philip Nell
  • Saker Nusseibeh
  • Silvia Dall’Angelo
  • Tatiana Bosteels
  • Tim Crockford
  • Tommaso Mancuso
  • Yasmin Chowdhury

Find posts by category

  • eos

Press contacts