Whichever way you cut it, 2024 will be a testing year for some of the world’s biggest democracies. Seven of the world’s ten most populous nations will go to the polls, accounting for a third of global GDP and a quarter of its population (see charts and table below).
In May, India’s billion-strong electorate will decide whether Prime Minister Narendra Modi deserves a third term in office. Mexicans vote for a new president in June, while in South Africa the ruling ANC faces its biggest electoral test since the end of apartheid.
November will be all about the US as voters decide whether their incumbent or former president should hold the keys to the White House. Then, at a date to be confirmed – though probably early Autumn – UK voters will decide whether to extend the 12-year majority of the Conservative Party.
The implications for investors could be significant. Read on to find out the views of our investment teams.
Our fund manager views
Charlotte Daughtrey, Equity Investment Specialist, Federated Hermes Limited
With both Biden and Trump securing their nominations, the start of 2024 rhymes with 2020. We don’t offer a view on the outcome – our crystal ball is no less cloudy than others’ – but what is important for markets is that this is a relatively de-risked election campaign, with both candidates having previously served in the office.
What’s sure is that both will want a strong economy and that tends to be good for markets too. The S&P has delivered an average annualised return of +6.2% in every election year since the Hoover administration. Further, US SMID companies have outperformed their large cap peers in every election year as far back as the data goes.1
All of which is to say, we don’t shape our portfolio for the outcome of the presidential election since we see no need. We believe that high quality companies with strong barriers to entry will outperform, regardless of the president or the economic cycle.
Perry Noble, Head of Infrastructure, Federated Hermes Infrastructure
Although no date has been set, the UK election must take place before 28 January, 2025. Commentators currently expect Prime Minister Rishi Sunak to call the election in autumn 2024 but there remains an outside chance of an earlier date.
While neither party has published a manifesto setting out their policies for governing, both the opposition Labour Party and the Conservative Party have made various pledges that would, if implemented, affect spending on infrastructure over the next five years.
The reality is that the scope for significant investment in infrastructure, including on energy transition and the decarbonisation of the UK economy, is limited by the state of the country’s public finances. UK government debt equated to 97.7% of GDP at the end of 2023. It was less than 30% in 1990. Policies implemented to cushion the impact of the pandemic and the energy inflation spike as a result of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine have reduced the country’s borrowing capacity.
While the UK’s debt-to-GDP ratio sits in the middle of the G7 pack, the country spends more on servicing its debt than any other G7 economy. Both parties have pledged to reduce the debt mountain over the life of the next Parliament. As shown by Labour’s recent row-back on its green investment commitment, the sums do not permit both investment and reduced public borrowing. It is unlikely that private capital will fill the gap.
Vincent Nobel, Head of Asset-Based Lending, Federated Hermes Private Credit
From a real estate investor’s point of view, it’s important that the general election happens as soon as possible. The uncertainty around the timing of the election has been unhelpful; and the sooner we have some certainty the better. Above all, real estate investors value stability. With 16 different housing ministers since 2010, it is something that’s been lacking in recent years.
Whether or not a new Labour government can provide the required level of stability or address some of the challenges facing the sector is a moot point right now – and will be until after the electorate have had their say and cast their vote.
Mark Russell, Head of Fund Management, Real Estate, Federated Hermes
Occupier demand for appropriate and relevant real estate in the UK is robust, and many segments have recorded record rents. However, investor demand remains subdued because of wider macro uncertainties related to the hikes in interest rates by the Bank of England in its fight with inflation. Markets dislike uncertainty – and a lack of forward conviction around monetary policy, consequential debt terms and forward asset valuations, together with various unknowns around a general election later in the year, have been unhelpful.
Clarity of policy should emerge from the main political parties as we head towards the election. If a similar clarity around the direction of monetary policy also emerges, then we would expect investor confidence to rebound and market liquidity to return.
Vivek Bhutoria, Co-Portfolio Manager, Federated Hermes Global Emerging Markets Equity Fund
The general elections in April-May this year carry profound implications for the Indian economy and equity markets. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is seeking a third term in office, and following his Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) strong performance in the recent state elections, he is widely expected to triumph. The anti-BJP opposition Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance (often referred to as the ‘I.N.D.I.A.’) was not very active in the recent state elections and it has not yet been able to formulate a seat-sharing plan for the national elections.
Modi is popular (enjoying an approval rating of 60-70% during his tenure) and remains a key factor in the BJP’s prospects at the ballot box. A win for the BJP would be positive for market sentiment because it would encourage political stability and lead to the continuation of Modi’s reform programme. Key reforms under his government include a combination of ‘bottom-of-pyramid’ policies (financial inclusion, direct benefit transfers, electricity for all); tough economic reforms (a nationwide goods-and-services tax that creates a unified domestic market; corporate tax cuts, a real-estate regulation act, a bankruptcy code, digital reforms, and a privatisation programme) and sensible fiscal imperatives (record government capex, investment in infrastructure and incentives to encourage manufacturing).
A continuation of the incumbent government should provide continuity in policies, offering stability and predictability to investors. Key economic issues such as fiscal management, infrastructure development, taxation, and job creation feature prominently in election campaigns. Furthermore, the outcome of the elections could influence foreign investor sentiment towards India. A clear electoral mandate and a government perceived as pro-business and investor-friendly will likely attract foreign investment inflows, supporting equity markets and bolstering economic growth.
Mo Elmi, Senior Portfolio Manager, Emerging Markets Fixed Income
The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) strong performance in last year’s state elections bodes well for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s efforts to get re-elected for a third term.
Although Modi has been accused of interfering with the independence of the judiciary, undermining parliamentary oversight and discriminating against religious minorities, he has been lauded for leading India in its ascension as a global power. We believe a Modi victory will lead to a continuation of India’s robust economic growth path of recent years.
Aldo Ruiz, Senior Analyst, Federated Hermes Limited
Mexico is set to elect a new president, all seats in Congress (128 senate seats and 500 lower house seats) and nine state governors, on 2 June this year. The presidential election looks likely to be a two-horse race between former Mexico City mayor Claudia Sheinbaum, from the left-wing Morena party, and senator Xochitl Galvez, from the conservative National Action Party (PAN), which means the country could be poised to have its first female president.
Sheinbaum – the ruling coalition candidate chosen to succeed incumbent Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador (AMLO) – holds a big lead in the polls. She has a PhD in environmental engineering and served as Head of Government of Mexico City between 2018 to 2023. Sheinbaum has remained loyal to AMLO but it’s unlikely she will continue with all of AMLO’s policies. She has, for example, voiced concerns about the energy sector, arguing Mexico cannot rely on fossil fuels in the future and that the private sector needs to be more involved, a 180-degree shift from AMLO’s rhetoric.
Galvez has a degree in computer engineering and a background in consulting. She also established a foundation to fight childhood malnutrition. She was the head of Mexico’s national institute of indigenous people under PAN President Vicente Fox (2000-06) and won a senate seat in 2018.
Mo Elmi, Senior Portfolio Manager, Emerging Markets Fixed Income
Claudia Sheinbaum, from the left-wing MORENA Party2 founded by outgoing President Andrés Manuel López Obrado (AMLO)3, is expected to win June’s presidential election.
Although we expect a continuation of current policies, Sheinbaum’s popularity is not as high as that of her predecessor. Therefore, we expect an uptick in social spending (and as a result higher fiscal deficits) as she looks to shore-up her position. It is worth remembering that her party lacks a supermajority, so Sheinbaum may struggle to pass any major reforms.
Jon De Vos, Senior Analyst, Federated Hermes Limited
General elections in South Africa are likely to take place in May and are poised to be the most closely contested of the democratic era. Disdain for the ruling African National Congress (ANC) has become widespread after three decades in power; large swathes of the population have yet to see material improvements in their living standards and the party has been plagued by corruption scandals.
Latest polls show ANC could lose its majority for the first time since the end of apartheid (one poll suggested just 39% of people intend to vote for the party). High unemployment, electricity blackouts and persistent crime rates are among the issues weighing on voters’ minds.
However, it would be premature to dismiss the possibility of the ANC retaining its majority. The ruling party holds a number of formidable advantages: it is deeply rooted in many communities and viewed as the only ‘anti-apartheid’ option by many people. It also benefits from excellent organisational networks and the country’s generous welfare system. Moreover, President Cyril Ramaphosa is popular and consistently polls ahead of the party. But these advantages no longer seem insurmountable, and the centrist Democratic Alliance (DA) has emerged as a viable alternative.
Another change this election cycle is the level of coordination between various opposition parties, led by DA leader John Steenhuisen. He has created the Multi-Party Charter (MPC), an 11-party agreement to form a coalition after the election, which has generated interest from voters. A recent poll showed that 38% of people who were familiar with the MPC said that they would vote for the members of the alliance.
Mo Elmi, Senior Portfolio Manager, Emerging Markets Fixed Income
Thirty years after the birth of the rainbow nation, the ruling African National Congress (ANC) and President Cyril Ramaphosa face a critical national election at the end of May.
With high unemployment, power shortages, low growth, and crumbling infrastructure, the ANC faces the prospect of polling under 50% for the first time. Populists such as the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) led by Julius Malema – with radical policIes such as land redistribution and nationalisation – are expected to eat into the ANC vote, as will a reinvigorated mainstream opposition Democratic Alliance (DA).
However, with the old liberation vote still strong, we expect Ramaphosa to get re-elected but forced to govern through a coalition, which will increase the overall uncertainty about South Africa’s future direction.
For more on elections in 2024 and how they might affect the investment landscape, please see the latest video from our Unconstrained Credit team.